New Lawsuit Reveals More About AI Error That Put Baltimore Teens in Police Crosshairs Over a Bag of Chips - Black Therapy Today
News

New Lawsuit Reveals More About AI Error That Put Baltimore Teens in Police Crosshairs Over a Bag of Chips

New Lawsuit Reveals More About AI Error That Put Baltimore Teens in Police Crosshairs Over a Bag of Chips

One second, they were teenagers hanging out after football practice, enjoying snacks and waiting for a ride home. Minutes later, Baltimore police officers were on the scene with their guns drawn, ordering them to the ground. For four Black students in Baltimore, an ordinary afternoon became a terrifying encounter that could have ended very differently– all because an artificial intelligence security system mistook a bag of chips for a loaded weapon. The Root previously reported on the incident. Now, the students are taking legal action as new details emerge about what went wrong.

According to the lawsuit, filed Nov. 17, the incident happened over a year ago on Oct. 20, 2025, outside Kenwood High School in Baltimore. One student, Taki Allen, had a bag of Cool Ranch Doritos in his pocket when an Omnilert Gun Detect system reportedly generated an alert indicating a 90% probability of a firearm.

The alert was canceled within two minutes of being issued. Still, the students– Allen, Yui-Osa Ogbeide, Devon Thompson Jr. and Keith Winfield III– allege that police officers arrived with weapons drawn, ordered them to their knees, handcuffed them and searched them– even though the threat had already been deemed unfounded.

Allen described the terrifying encounter to NBC News. “The first thing I thought about was, ‘Am I about to die?’ because they had a gun pointed at me.”

RELATED: How AI Caused Police to Surround a Black Baltimore Teen With Guns Out Over — a Bag of Doritos?

The lawsuit argues that the incident was not simply a technological mistake, but a series of failures involving both artificial intelligence and the people responsible for reviewing its alerts.

“The police told my son this could have been a real problem. No child in Baltimore County should face this kind of danger while waiting outside his own school for a ride home from his mother,” one parent, Freida Winfield, said in a statement.

The Maryland Office of the Inspector General for Education (OIGE) had already investigated the incident in a November 2025 report. Its findings add another layer to the controversy. Investigators concluded that the system did not actually identify a Doritos bag as a weapon. Instead, it flagged the student’s hand movements, the position of his hand and an unidentified object extending beyond his fingers.

The report also found that school officials and a Baltimore County police representative initially reviewed the alert, determined it was invalid and issued a cancellation notice. However, communication failures meant the cancellation did not stop the police response.

“Despite these internal control protocols, [Baltimore County Public Schools] lost their authority and ability to control external alert notifications and their response methods when law enforcement is involved,” the report concluded. “…The loss of alert notification controls could place not only BCPS staff and students at risk but could also place responding law enforcement in a potentially tragic situation.”

Investigators found no evidence of racial bias in Omnilert’s detection algorithm. However, that finding does not resolve the lawsuit’s allegations concerning the treatment of the Black students or the decisions made by the adults involved.

The lawsuit seeks accountability and changes to how schools and police respond to AI-generated threats. The Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights Under Law says the case highlights the dangers of relying on technology without adequate human oversight, particularly when Black children are involved.

“Overreliance on artificial intelligence technology mixed with inept communication and coordination among key officials is a toxic mix,” president and executive director of the Lawyers’ Committee for Civil Rights Under Law, Damon Hewitt, declared.