Could This Black Mother’s Tragic Case Predict the Fate of Lindsay Clancy’s Postpartum Psychosis Defense?

As a Massachusetts jury weighs whether Lindsay Clancy was criminally responsible for the deaths of her three children, a New York judge has reached a separate conclusion in a strikingly similar case involving postpartum psychosis.

Dimone Fleming, a 26-year-old Black mother from the Bronx, was found not guilty by reason of insanity in the 2022 deaths of her two young sons, Daishawn Fleming, 3, and Octavius Canada, 11 months, according to ABC 7 New York. On Aug. 24, a judge determined that Fleming was not criminally responsible because she was suffering from severe mental illness at the time of the crime.

The ruling came just as the jury in Clancy’s Massachusetts murder trial entered deliberations in the high-profile case.

Clancy, a former labor and delivery nurse, is accused of killing her three children before attempting suicide. Her defense argued that she was experiencing postpartum psychosis and therefore lacked criminal responsibility for her actions. Prosecutors have disputed that account, arguing that she knew what she was doing and acted deliberately.

RELATED: Update: Five of The Pregnant and Postpartum Women Jailed in Alabama Have Been Released

Monday (Aug. 31) marks day three of deliberations for the Massachusetts jury. But the Fleming case has added another level of debate over maternal health and Postpartum psychosis that some mothers experience.

Postpartum psychosis is rare, but it can be devastating. After giving birth, a mother can lose touch with reality, experiencing hallucinations, delusions and thoughts or behaviors that can put herself or others at risk, according to the Cleveland Clinic. In severe cases, the psychosis can lead to dangerous and even fatal thoughts and outcomes.

According to prosecutors and defense psychiatrists in Fleming’s case, she had previously been diagnosed with major depressive disorder, and investigators said she had stopped taking prescribed medication. Her condition was also reportedly worsened by regular marijuana use, PEOPLE reported.

Fleming believed her children needed to be “cleansed” of evil, according to court records. Their bodies were later found in a bathtub with multiple stab wounds, ABC 7 New York also reported. Medical examiners confirmed the children were then submerged in the tub water.

At the time of the killings, the 11-month-old’s father was allegedly sleeping in a car outside the apartment after Fleming told security not to let him inside the building, according to police. When officers arrived at the scene, they found Fleming inside her home naked while trying to burn items in the kitchen.

She was initially charged with two counts each of murder, intention to murder and depraved indifference, records show.

But this month, the prosecution and defense agreed on Fleming’s mental state, allowing the case to be resolved without a murder trial. Fleming remains in custody while she undergoes additional psychiatric evaluation. Another hearing is scheduled for September, according to The New York Times.

Clancy’s case has been far more contested.

Her defense has presented postpartum psychosis as the central explanation for the killings. The jury heard testimony from more than 80 witnesses, including Clancy’s husband, medical professionals who treated her and psychiatrists during the five-week trial.

The Fleming ruling does not determine what will happen in Clancy’s courtroom. But it underscores the central issue facing the Massachusetts jury: whether a mother suffering from a severe postpartum psychiatric disorder can be held criminally responsible for the deaths of her children and what happens after the damage is already done.