$100K Lawsuit Adds New Chapter to Bitter Surrogacy Fight

The baby at the center of a tense surrogacy fight is now out of the womb, but the legal battle surrounding his birth is only getting messier.

As we previously reported, McKenna West, a 28-year-old Alaska nurse who served as a gestational surrogate for California couple Nausheen Gilkar and Omar Ahmed, gave birth Aug. 12 in Texas. The baby, diagnosed during pregnancy with a serious heart condition, was born after months of disagreement over whether the pregnancy should continue.

Now, the biological parents are taking another legal step.

Gilkar and Ahmed are suing West for more than $100,000, alleging that she breached their contract by refusing to terminate the pregnancy, according to the New York Post. They say West’s actions caused them financial and emotional damage and accuse her of violating the agreement they entered before the pregnancy. West has challenged the contract and argued that enforcing an abortion provision against her would violate her bodily autonomy.

RELATED: The Legal Stakes Surrounding a Black Surrogate Mother’s Fight For Bodily Autonomy

According to the Mayo Clinic, hypoplastic left heart syndrome is a rare condition in which the left side of the heart is severely underdeveloped. Babies with the condition typically require a series of complicated surgeries. West said she felt pressured to have an abortion after doctors discovered the heart defect at about 20 weeks. Gilkar and Ahmed deny forcing her to terminate the pregnancy, according to NBC News. Their attorneys say their surrogacy agreement included a provision allowing an abortion in the event of a serious fetal abnormality.

West ultimately refused and traveled from Alaska to Texas, where abortion is illegal in nearly all circumstances, The Root also reported. The dispute then moved into multiple courtrooms, with questions about the enforceability of the surrogacy agreement, parental rights and who should make medical decisions for the baby.

Meanwhile, the baby – whom West calls Gabriel and the biological parents named Rumi – is undergoing the intensive medical treatment doctors warned would be necessary, including a recent Norwood procedure, “a complex palliative heart surgery,” according to the family’s lawyer. The procedure is designed to reroute blood flow so the heart can support the body.

The biological parents currently have custody and are with the baby as he receives treatment. West remains involved in the broader custody fight and is seeking parental rights.

The case is now about far more than one surrogacy contract. It has become a collision of reproductive autonomy, abortion, parental rights and the limits of what prospective parents can demand from someone carrying their child.

And with a newborn recovering from lifesaving surgery at the center of it all, the legal questions are becoming increasingly difficult to separate from the human ones.